Towing a boat, a horse float, or a decent-sized caravan is where the diesel-versus-hybrid argument in New Zealand gets genuinely interesting.
Get an instant price for thisTowing a boat, a horse float, or a decent-sized caravan is where the diesel-versus-hybrid argument in New Zealand gets genuinely interesting. The Prado and the Highlander Hybrid both turn up on the same shortlists for buyers who want one vehicle that can do the school run on Monday and pull a trailer to Taupo on Friday, but they solve the towing problem in completely different ways.
The towing numbers
| Prado (2.8L turbo-diesel) | Highlander Hybrid | |
|---|---|---|
| Braked towing capacity | 3,000 kg | 1,588 kg |
| Unbraked towing capacity | 750 kg | 750 kg |
| Gross combination mass | 5,990 kg | Not rated for heavy combinations |
| Kerb weight | ~2,205 kg | ~2,000 kg |
This is the number that ends most debates before they start. The Prado's 3,000 kg braked rating comfortably covers a loaded double horse float, a 6-metre boat on a trailer, or a mid-size caravan. The Highlander Hybrid's 1,588 kg rating is genuinely useful for a small boat, a single horse float, or a box trailer, but it rules out anything heavier.
Why the gap is so large
The Highlander's hybrid system prioritises efficiency over sustained torque delivery, and its transaxle-style hybrid transmission isn't engineered for the heat load of prolonged heavy towing. Toyota rates it conservatively partly for warranty reasons and partly because the electric motors and battery pack don't appreciate extended high-current draw under load on long uphill pulls, like the climb out of Ohakune or the grade up the Kaimai Range.
The Prado's ladder-frame chassis, low-range transfer case, and 2.8-litre turbo-diesel with genuine low-down torque (typically around 500 Nm) is a completely different engineering brief. It's built to sit at 100 km/h towing a loaded float up the Desert Road without drama, and to do it repeatedly for years without the driveline complaining.
Fuel use towing versus not towing
| | Prado unladen | Prado towing 2,500 kg | Highlander Hybrid unladen | Highlander Hybrid towing 1,400 kg | |---|---|---|---| | Real-world L/100km | 8.5–9.5 | 13–15 | 6.5–7.2 | 9.5–11 |
The diesel Prado's fuel economy takes a bigger absolute hit under load, but diesel is typically 15–20 cents a litre cheaper than 91 octane at most NZ pumps, which softens the difference in running cost. Over a 15,000 km year with occasional towing, Prado owners typically report annual fuel spend of $2,400–$2,900, against $1,900–$2,300 for a Highlander Hybrid used mostly unladen with occasional light towing.
Everyday driving and running costs
Away from towing duties, the comparison flips. The Highlander Hybrid is quieter, smoother, and noticeably cheaper to service — Toyota hybrid servicing in NZ typically runs $180–$280 per visit versus $320–$420 for a diesel Prado service that includes DPF and EGR attention. The Prado's diesel particulate filter can also be a genuine headache for owners who do mostly short urban trips, since DPFs need sustained highway running to regenerate properly; a vehicle bought primarily for towing but used mostly for the school run can end up with expensive DPF problems within a few years.
Off-road and rough-terrain capability
If your towing involves getting to the launch ramp, the yards, or a backcountry hunting block over unsealed roads, the Prado's low-range gearing and greater ground clearance (around 220 mm versus the Highlander's 203 mm) matter. The Highlander Hybrid has front-wheel-drive or on-demand AWD depending on trim, which is fine for gravel and light snow but not designed for genuine off-road recovery situations.
Resale and ownership costs
| Prado (2018–2021, used import/NZ new) | Highlander Hybrid (2021–2023) | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical asking price | $58,000–$78,000 | $54,000–$68,000 |
| 5-year resale retention | Strong — often 60–65% of new price | Good — typically 55–60% |
Prados hold value exceptionally well in NZ because demand from rural buyers, towing users, and export markets stays consistently high. Highlander Hybrids depreciate at a normal-to-good rate but don't command the same premium from towing-focused buyers.
Which one actually suits you
Choose the Prado if: you regularly tow anything over 1.6 tonnes, need low-range for unsealed or steep access roads, or want a vehicle built around towing as its primary job rather than an occasional one.
Choose the Highlander Hybrid if: your towing is genuinely occasional and light — a small trailer, jet ski, or single-axle box trailer under 1,500 kg — and you'd rather have lower fuel bills and cheaper servicing for the other 90% of your driving.
We see plenty of buyers who assume "hybrid" automatically means "capable enough," then discover the towing rating doesn't stretch to what they actually need. If towing is a genuine, regular requirement rather than a once-a-year job, the diesel Prado remains the more honest tool for the task.
Need help with your hybrid or EV?
Get an instant price estimate for battery replacement, diagnostics, or parts.
Get a quote — 60 seconds