EV battery fires get outsized attention online, and it's a question nearly every hesitant buyer asks us at some point: are electric cars actually more likely to catch fire than petrol ones?
Get an instant price for thisEV battery fires get outsized attention online, and it's a question nearly every hesitant buyer asks us at some point: are electric cars actually more likely to catch fire than petrol ones? The data says no, but the nature of an EV fire when it does happen is different enough that the fear isn't entirely irrational either. Here's the honest picture.
What the actual numbers show
Multiple insurance industry studies, including data from Scandinavian markets with the highest EV adoption rates in the world, consistently show internal combustion vehicles catch fire at a meaningfully higher rate per 100,000 vehicles than EVs do. Petrol vehicles have decades of fuel system, wiring, and engine-bay ignition sources that EVs simply don't have.
Where EV fires do occur, the leading causes are:
- Physical damage to the battery pack — a severe underbody impact or collision
- Manufacturing defects in a small number of battery packs (subject to recalls when identified)
- Charging faults, usually from damaged cables or non-compliant aftermarket charging equipment
- Water ingress after flood exposure, which can short cells internally
Why EV fires feel scarier even though they're rarer
When a lithium-ion battery pack does ignite, it behaves differently to a petrol fire:
- It can involve thermal runaway, where one damaged cell heats neighbouring cells until they also ignite
- It's harder to extinguish with a standard fire extinguisher — often requires large volumes of water for cooling
- It can reignite hours or even days later if not fully cooled
- Fire crews need specific training and protocols for EV fires, which are still being rolled out across some NZ regions
This is why an EV fire, though rare, tends to generate a lot more media coverage and lingering owner anxiety than a garden-variety engine bay fire in an old petrol car.
Flood damage is the real NZ-specific risk
New Zealand's increasingly frequent severe weather events are actually the most relevant fire risk factor for EV owners here. A battery pack submerged in floodwater, even briefly, can suffer internal short circuits that don't show symptoms immediately — sometimes not for days afterwards.
If your EV or PHEV has been in floodwater:
- Do not attempt to charge it or drive it
- Have it inspected by a qualified technician before doing anything else
- Insurance write-offs are common for flood-affected EVs even with no visible external damage, because the risk isn't worth carrying forward
What we tell customers considering a used EV
- Ask for the vehicle's accident and flood history, not just a standard vehicle report
- A battery health check from a workshop like ours will flag abnormal cell behaviour that could indicate prior damage
- Avoid cheap, non-certified aftermarket charging cables — this is a genuine, avoidable risk factor
- Don't leave a damaged 12V or HV battery unattended without having it assessed
The bottom line
Statistically, you are less likely to have your EV catch fire than an equivalent petrol car. The bigger practical risk in NZ specifically is flood exposure given our weather patterns, and the sensible response is the same either way — get anything you're unsure about properly inspected rather than guessing. If you've had a knock, a flood, or anything that makes you wonder about your battery's condition, book a battery health check before you keep driving on it.
Need help with your hybrid or EV?
Get an instant price estimate for battery replacement, diagnostics, or parts.
Get a quote — 60 seconds