The purchase price gap between an EV and an equivalent petrol car has narrowed considerably, but plenty of NZ buyers still assume the petrol option is cheaper overall because the sticker price is lower.
Get an instant price for thisThe purchase price gap between an EV and an equivalent petrol car has narrowed considerably, but plenty of NZ buyers still assume the petrol option is cheaper overall because the sticker price is lower. Run the numbers over five years and the picture usually flips. Here's a realistic comparison based on a mid-size SUV, a common cross-shop in this market.
The comparison vehicles
For this exercise, we're comparing a mid-size electric SUV (comparable to a Kona Electric or MG4 SUV variant) against an equivalent petrol mid-size SUV, both purchased new, both driven 15,000 km per year, over five years.
Purchase price
| Electric | Petrol | |
|---|---|---|
| New price | $58,000 | $46,000 |
| Price gap | +$12,000 | — |
Fuel and energy costs over 5 years
| Electric | Petrol | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual cost | $450 (mostly home charging) | $2,800 (at ~$2.85/L, 7.5L/100km) |
| 5-year total | $2,250 | $14,000 |
Servicing and maintenance over 5 years
| Electric | Petrol | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual average | $350 | $1,100 |
| 5-year total | $1,750 | $5,500 |
This includes brake fluid, cabin filters, tyres, and the occasional coolant service for the EV; oil changes, filters, spark plugs, and standard scheduled maintenance for the petrol car.
Tyres over 5 years
EVs wear tyres faster due to weight and instant torque, partly offsetting the maintenance savings above:
| Electric | Petrol | |
|---|---|---|
| 5-year total | $2,200 | $1,600 |
Depreciation (5-year retained value)
| Electric | Petrol | |
|---|---|---|
| Retained value % | ~42% | ~38% |
| Value retained | $24,360 | $17,480 |
| Depreciation cost | $33,640 | $28,520 |
EVs from reputable brands with good battery health documentation are increasingly holding value comparably to, or better than, petrol equivalents — a shift from just a few years ago when EV depreciation was a bigger concern.
Total 5-year cost of ownership
| Category | Electric | Petrol |
|---|---|---|
| Depreciation | $33,640 | $28,520 |
| Fuel/energy | $2,250 | $14,000 |
| Servicing | $1,750 | $5,500 |
| Tyres | $2,200 | $1,600 |
| Total | $39,840 | $49,620 |
The result
Despite the higher purchase price, the EV comes out roughly $9,800 cheaper over five years in this scenario, driven almost entirely by the fuel/energy savings, which alone nearly cover the entire purchase price gap. The petrol car's advantage in tyre costs and slightly better depreciation percentage doesn't come close to offsetting the running cost gap.
Where the maths shifts
This comparison favours the EV more heavily for higher-mileage drivers (fuel savings scale directly with kilometres driven) and less so for very low-mileage drivers, where the smaller annual fuel bill narrows the gap and the higher purchase price takes longer to recoup. A driver doing 8,000 km a year might take 6–7 years to reach cost parity rather than the roughly 3.5-year crossover point implied by the 15,000 km scenario above.
Variables that can change the outcome
- Home charging access — without it, relying on public DC fast charging can push EV energy costs close to or above petrol costs
- Battery health at resale — a poorly maintained battery drags down resale value and can erase the cost advantage
- Petrol price volatility — the comparison above uses a moderate fuel price; higher petrol prices widen the EV's advantage further
Bottom line
For an average or higher-mileage NZ driver with home charging access, an EV typically wins on total 5-year cost despite the higher purchase price, usually reaching cost parity somewhere between years three and four before pulling ahead.
Need help with your hybrid or EV?
Get an instant price estimate for battery replacement, diagnostics, or parts.
Get a quote — 60 seconds